The recent Gauteng High Court case of Chantelle v Designer Group (Pty) Ltd dealt with the tricky similar goods issue. In this case the mark was identical – one company had registered Chantelle for ladies undergarments (class 25), the other wanted to register Chantelle for cosmetics (class 3). With identical marks, the only issue was whether the goods were so similar that there was a likelihood of confusion.
Yes said the judge. But he probably had to, because the SCA made such a finding back in 1991 in the famous case of Danco Clothing (Pty) Ltd v Nu-Care Marketing. There the court held that a registration for French Connection for clothing was enough to stop registration of French Connection for cosmetics. The court’s finding there was based on the fact it was bound to consider notional use of the mark on both clothing and cosmetics, and that such notional use encompassed products being sold in the same stores and in close proximity. It also recognised the practice of brand extension.
The judge in the Chantelle case followed this reasoning: ‘It is likely that the average observant consumer of the appellant’s goods, stumbling upon the respondent’s cosmetics bearing the identical mark, notionally in the same shop and notionally a few counters away, would be confused and deceived into believing…that the cosmetics of the respondent originate from the same source.’
The judge also considered the old British Sugar case, which says that you must consider the following factors when determining similarity: the uses of the goods; the users of the goods; the physical nature of the goods; the trade channels; whether they’re found on same shelves; whether they’re competitive.
Clothing and cosmetics are very different in nature, so the judge in the Chantelle case concentrated on trade channels:‘Importantly, the appellant’s goods can notionally be sold in any fashion outlet, including stores such as Edgars, Truworths and others where cosmetics and fragrances are located and sold in close proximity to clothing and other garments.’ And he suggested that the goods are competitive, because clothing brands often extend to cosmetics – there’s mention of Hugo Boss, Chanel, Puma…
It’s a far cry from some of the decisions we’ve had of late. Like the SCA decision which held that Zonquasdrif could co-exist for wine and wine grapes because the goods are not so similar that confusion will arise. Or the case involving co-existence of the mark Due South, where the court suggested that if goods are in different classes they aren’t similar. Our law’s a bit of mess on this point right now.
It’s imperative to locate a mentor who focuses on exactly the same
game version and is effective within the same restriction you intend to become successful in.
108702 140419if this post was likened to a flavor of yogurt, what flavor would it be? Banana, I believe. 519801
433133 49605Can I simply say exactly what a relief to get someone who in fact knows what theyre dealing with on the internet. You truly know how to bring a difficulty to light and make it essential. The diet must see this and fully grasp this side on the story. I cant believe youre not a lot more common because you undoubtedly hold the gift. 246569
748477 739527I enjoy your wp format, exactly where did you get a hold of it? 353421
994866 413167Simply wanna input which you have a extremely nice website , I enjoy the pattern it really stands out. 398555
795470 474514I really enjoy examining on this internet internet site , it has got great posts . 674327
149411 603702I like you weblog (dsol, je suis francais, je parle mal anglais) 177259
627428 437791Id ought to verify with you here. Which isnt something I often do! I enjoy studying a publish that can make folks believe. Also, thanks for permitting me to remark! 692170
62454 65218Some times its a pain inside the ass to read what weblog owners wrote but this internet web site is genuinely user genial ! . 872916
615188 377077We offer the most effective practical and most applicable solutions. All our Sydney plumbers are experienced and qualified and are able to quickly assess your difficulty and locate the most effective answer. 155815
500468 176917Would adore to constantly get updated great web blog ! . 460566
129818 782183Nice article. It does shed some light on the concern. By the for those interested in binary options can get an exclusive binary options bonus. 475742
218180 923842Id require to consult you here. Which isnt some thing Which i do! I enjoy reading a post that can make people feel. Also, appreciate your allowing me to comment! 765540
278968 41032Id always want to be update on new blog posts on this internet website , bookmarked ! . 566053
321071 328243Some truly marvelous function on behalf with the owner of this internet web site , dead fantastic articles . 410032
737255 992615You should participate in a contest for among the very best blogs on the internet. I will suggest this site! 177052
198953 275695An intriguing discussion will probably be worth comment. Im confident which you want to write more about this subject, it might not be a taboo subject but typically consumers are too couple of to chat on such topics. To an additional. Cheers 213051
595209 936887Thanks for this outstanding. I was wondering whether you were preparing of writing comparable posts to this one. .Keep up the outstanding articles! 640743
761161 6644The entire glance of your web site is fantastic, let well as the content material! 476441
513806 951293Simply wanna remark which you have a very good internet web site , I enjoy the layout it really stands out. 646656
771513 434222Respect to internet site author , some amazing entropy. 167804
228260 670822But, what in regards to the bottom line? Are you sure about the supply? 293208
365143 462996I really got into this post. I found it to be interesting and loaded with distinctive points of interest. I like to read material that makes me believe. Thank you for writing this fantastic content material. 880758
772190 244631I dugg some of you post as I cogitated they were very beneficial invaluable 667788
621668 134575Really fighter messages are supposed to amuse offer praise into the groom and bride. 1st time audio system watching over the top places need to also remember you see, the senior guideline with the speaking, which is your certain person. greatest man speeches brother 969748
241002 321180I think so. I feel your write-up will give those individuals a very good reminding. And they will express thanks to you later 695242
720757 428259Some truly nice and valuable information on this site, likewise I conceive the style holds outstanding attributes. 472356
38597 508423We offer the top practical and most applicable solutions. All our Sydney plumbers are experienced and qualified and are able to quickly assess your issue and discover the top answer. 143645
710978 128883An intriguing discussion will probably be worth comment. I think which you simply write much more about this topic, it might become a taboo subject but normally consumers are inadequate to communicate in on such topics. To an additional. Cheers 520839
74364 292024Merely a smiling visitor here to share the adore (:, btw outstanding style . “Audacity, far more audacity and always audacity.” by Georges Jacques Danton. 478646
381563 142800My brother suggested I would possibly like this weblog. He was once entirely proper. This submit in fact created my day. You cant believe just how so a lot time I had spent for this details! Thank you! 89671
298714 664041Sweet internet site , super pattern , rattling clean and use friendly . 722340
873969 853423Thanks for the information provided! I was finding for this details for a long time, but I wasnt able to find a reliable source. 732668
795072 441715Some times its a discomfort in the ass to read what folks wrote but this website is real user genial ! . 776910
568874 749420This Los angeles Weight Loss diet happens to be an low and flexible going on a diet application meant for typically trying to drop the weight as nicely within the have a much healthier lifetime. lose weight 954628
397342 675171This internet internet site may possibly be a walk-through for all of the details you wanted in regards to this and didnt know who to question. Glimpse here, and youll certainly discover it. 904172
881875 441574This web website is often a walk-through for all with the information you wanted concerning this and didnt know who must. Glimpse here, and youll totally discover it. 804802
867302 494532I like your writing style really loving this web website . 649245
227159 315927Utterly composed subject material , thanks for selective data . 170042
867566 312669A person necessarily lend a hand to make severely posts Id state. This really is the very first time I frequented your web page and to this point? I surprised with the analysis you created to make this particular submit extraordinary. Magnificent process! 358207
833220 221112you are in point of fact a great webmaster. The web site loading velocity is incredible. It seems that youre performing any distinctive trick. In addition, The contents are masterpiece. youve done an excellent activity on this subject! 804340
218485 915035Very fascinating details!Perfect just what I was seeking for! 960717
808537 899886Yeah bookmaking this wasnt a high risk determination outstanding post! . 488850
654837 176157Most what i read online is trash and copy paste but i feel you offer something different. Maintain it like this. 838298
790829 896957I discovered your blog site on google and verify a few of your early posts. Continue to preserve up the superb operate. I just extra up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Looking for forward to reading extra from you in a although! 140319
47538 945808You created some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found a lot of people will agree with your weblog. 867040
261767 88146informatii interesante si utile postate pe blogul dumneavoastra. dar ca si o paranteza , ce parere aveti de inchirierea apartamente vacanta ?. 520694
225290 128081Many thanks I ought say, impressed with your site. I will post this to my facebook wall. 199871
Hello, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues.
When I look at your website in Chrome, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer,
it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
Other then that, superb blog!
It’s really great. Thank you for providing a quality article. There is something you might be interested in. Do you know casinosite ? If you have more questions, please come to my site and check it out!
Someone necessarily help to make critically posts
I would state. This is the first time I frequented your website page
and so far? I surprised with the analysis you made to make
this particular publish incredible. Wonderful process!
Dear mooreattorneys.com owner, Your posts are always informative.
Sports betting, football betting, cricket betting, euroleague football betting,
aviator games, aviator games money – first deposit bonus up to 500 euros.Sign up bonus